“Most off-putting is the puritanical streak that eventually comes to dominate the film.”

“…a complicated and compelling film that’s uncomfortable in necessary ways.”

“…absurdly abstract in a way von Trier’s best films are not.”

“…attracted some Oscar attention, but not necessarily for the right people.”

“…laments World War II as a waste of Jiro’s gifts, of talent corrupted.”

“A tinderbox of movie charisma, yet even tinder needs to be lit.”

“…mostly registers as a sumptuous elegy.”

“Science-versus-religion debates don’t usually feature music this good.”

“… surprisingly digestible.”

“…a puppy-dog movie: it nips at your heels, yips in your ears and never lets up in its desire to please.”